Software that is distributed using embedded cryptographic signatures can pose a challenge to allow users to reproduce identical results. By definition, they will not be able to generate an identical signature. This can either be solved by making the signature part of the build process input or by offering tools to transform the distributed binaries to pristine build results.
One way to handle embedded cryptographic signatures is to make the signature an (optional) input of the build process. When a signature is available, it just gets copied at the right location.
This enables the following workflow:
- An initial build is made by the developers who have access to the private key.
- The build result is signed to an external file.
- The signature is made part of the released source code.
- The build that is going to be distributed is made from the latter source.
wireless-regdb package in Debian is an example on how this can be
A specific comparison tool can be made available that is able to compare to builds skipping the signatures. Ideally, it should also be able to produce cryptographic checksums to make downloading the original build unneeded to solely compare the results.
Such a tool must be very easy to audit and understand. Otherwise, it’s hard to trust that the script is not ignoring bytes that would make it behave differently.
Another option is to ship a tool that can strip the signatures from the official releases. The result can then be compared byte-for-byte with the results from the user.
This method has the downside that it requires a user to download the official releases to do the comparison. It’s also harder to attest that the data that is being removed will not make the software behave differently.
Achieve deterministic builds
- Deterministic build systems
- Volatile inputs can disappear
- Stable order for inputs
- Value initialization
- Version information
- Archive metadata
- Stable order for outputs
- Build path
- System images
Define a build environment
- What's in a build environment?
- Recording the build environment
- Definition strategies
- Proprietary operating systems
Distribute the environment
Follow us on Twitter @ReproBuilds, Mastodon @firstname.lastname@example.org & Reddit and please consider making a donation. • Content licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0, style licensed under MIT. Templates and styles based on the Tor Styleguide. Logos and trademarks belong to their respective owners. • Patches welcome via our Git repository (instructions) or via our mailing list. • Full contact info